07/27/2021
Many people are troubled by the story of Noah and the flood. And rightly so—especially by modern standards, this God is a monster. I’ve often heard the question, “How can we call this God loving?” As Rachel Held Evans puts it, “Is God the good guy or the bad guy in this story?”
Looking at historical and literary context can help. Every ancient Near Eastern society had a flood story—the Sumerians, the Hittites, the Babylonians, everyone. (In Sumer’s story, the protagonist’s sons are even named Shem, Ham, and Japheth! Hmm, it’s like Abraham came from there and brought his stories with him… shocker!) The key difference is that in all of the other literature, the gods are trying to wipe out everyone. The protagonists (Gilgamesh and others) have to outsmart or trick the gods in order to survive.
By comparison, Genesis’s God is kinder and more merciful, not only warning the main character but also instructing him in how to save his family and the animals. But in destroying everyone else, by modern standards, this God is still not great… but we find that in most eras of history. If we judge another era by today’s standards, we’re going to be disappointed and sometimes horrified. It’s better to look at which direction the Bible is moving from the status quo of its day than the absolute point of where it is. Human consciousness evolves over time, and the Bible reflects this movement towards more benevolence.
Rabbi Jonathan Sacks also comments that the glaring absence in the text is the fact that Noah does not beg God for mercy for his neighbors. When God tells Abraham he’s going to destroy S***m, Abraham starts bargaining. When God tells Cain He’s going to punish him, Cain protests that it’s too harsh. When God says He wants to destroy the Israelites for their sin and stubbornness, Moses appeals. The Hebrew Scriptures are full of people arguing against God for the sake of mercy, and God listening. Noah, by contrast, puts up no protest. Rabbi Sacks says that Noah is called a righteous man at the beginning of the story and never again afterwards—and his story ends in tragedy—because he does not intervene and ask God for mercy. His lack of compassion toward his fellow man begins the downturn of his story.
(Information from BEMA Discipleship podcast and “Covenant & Conversation” by Rabbi Jonathan Sacks)