09/09/2026
These large flowers from the straight species of New York Aster (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae) as well as the insect free foliage absolutely stunned me today. They looked so different and better than the many cultivars of New York Aster that I have planted over the years that it took me a long time to identify them.
They were growing in a swampy, wet spot, high in fertility and organic matter with a pH below 7 in the tallgrass prairie at the golf course. There were a few of the same species struggling in the much drier (well drained because of a steep slope), compacted clay, poor soil area of the tallgrass prairie; however, I did not realize they were the same plant. The much shorter ones with a few tiny, pathetic flowers growing in those poor, dry soil areas had foliage covered with Lace Bug damage and looked absolutely awful.
Herbaceous perennial plant guru Dr. Allan Armitage made a statement about New York Asters that caught my interest. 'This common wildflower is one of the largest and prettiest in the genus, but is seldom seen, having been superseded by newer, but not always better, cultivars.' Now I think I understand what Dr. Armitage means.
Today was an eye opener for me as I had no idea that New York Asters are so picky as to soil conditions for them to thrive and reach their potential for beauty! I have not planted New York Asters for years because I thought they always got rust and Lace Bug damage so badly by mid-summer that they were a lost cause. It appears that I did not know and did not provide the right conditions for them to thrive.
photo and post by Sam Bahr, horticulturist