04/24/2024
Each Wednesday, we highlight a book review from the Currents in Theology and Mission publication. Today, we're featuring a review of "God Can't: How to Believe in God and Love After Tragedy, Abuse, and Other Evils" by Thomas Jay Oord.
Below is a review from Wartburg graduate Anthony G. Windau:
Thomas Jay Oord makes the incredibly bold claim to “solve” the problem of evil within this text, and in five steps, no less. Oord begins his argument with two assumptions; first that God’s very being, or character, is love and of a loving nature (11). The second assumption is that gratuitous, or genuine, evil exists in the world (12-13). One can tell that these ideas are heavily influenced by Open Theism even without it being explicitly named in the text. With these in mind, Oord begins laying out his argument, one chapter per step, using real life stories and experiences to move theodicy from the realm of theory into lived reality.
In brief, Oord’s points are: First, God cannot prevent evil singlehandedly (17). Second, God truly feels creation’s pain and suffering (48). Third, God wants to heal those who have been harmed or experienced suffering (79). This third point has four subpoints within it, including God is omnipresent/loving, God walks alongside creation, God can’t heal singlehandedly, and God’s love extends beyond death (88-97). Fourth, God can “squeeze the good from the bad” (113). Finally, God requires our participation in solving evil (142).
Oord, in this text, successfully presents his solution to the ever-vexing problem of evil. Through his five steps, Oord identifies shortcomings of traditional images of God, offers his alternatives, and seeks a way forward. This book would be well worth the time of pastors and congregation members to engage in a new way of thinking about evil. It is up to the reader if Oord truly succeeds in answering the ancient question of evil.
Want to read more of this and other book reviews? Check out this link: http://www.currentsjournal.org/index.php/currents/article/view/453/491