10/30/2026
- As we close out Halloweek, we highlight another unusual item in our collection: “The Hairy Hand.”[1] This was a gift from a 1L class to Professor Clark Byse (1912-2007), who donated it to the library. The Hairy Hand is a nod to the famous contracts case, Hawkins v. McGee, which established an important principle about how courts calculate damages when someone fails to deliver a promised result.[2]
At age 11, George Hawkins' hand was scarred from contact with an electrical wire, after turning on the light in his family’s kitchen. A N.H. doctor, Edward McGee, guaranteed to make the injured hand “a hundred percent good hand.” McGee removed “a considerable quantity of scar tissue,” then used a skin-grafting technique (in which he had little previous experience) using skin from Hawkins' chest, which caused thick hair to grow on the palm of Hawkins' hand. In 1929 (about nine years after the initial incident), the New Hampshire Supreme Court held that Hawkins was entitled to the difference in value between what he was promised (“a hundred percent good hand”) and what he received (a hairy palm).
FunFactFriday2 – Prof. Byse served on the HLS faculty from 1957-2007. According to HLS’ Historical Faculty page, “A legend on the HLS campus and beyond, Byse was a leading scholar in administrative law and was also known for his vigorous support of academic freedom. He was believed by many to have been one of the inspirations for the composite character of Charles Kingsfield in ‘The Paper Chase,’ the novel by John Jay Osborn Jr. ’70, and the film and television series that followed.”[3]
Citations:
[1] Hairy Hand, Art; Acc. no. 2009.163.7. Donated by Professor Clark Byse.
[2] Hawkins v. McGee, 84 N.H. 114 (N.H. 1929).
[3] https://hls.harvard.edu/historical-faculty/clark-byse-1912-2007/